The tycoon’s lame duck debut brings home only a photo opportunity
(by Serena Di Ronza) Donald Trump defines Vladimir Putin as his “friend” and the storm immediately breaks out. In his return to the world stage after the bitter defeat in the mid-term elections, the president in China sees Putin face to face, in their first meeting after the Alaska summit in 2025. Entering the room at Kylin Villa, a five-star resort in Shenzen, a smiling Trump is filmed saying “who is he? He’s a friend of mine”, before approaching the Kremlin leader who was waiting for him. The two exchanged a warm handshake, then took their seats for their bilateral meeting. Trump’s enthusiastic words towards Putin have sparked a storm of controversy.
“God, protect us from such friends,” Polish Prime Minister Donald Tusk wrote on X. “Generally speaking, we don’t comment on friendships,” commented European Commission spokeswoman Paula Pinho laconically. “I would just like to remind you that Russia continues to launch devastating attacks against civilians and civilian infrastructure in Ukraine,” another European spokesperson explained.
Even at home, the president has been overwhelmed by criticism. Hillary Clinton accused him of “emboldening the dictator” and “weakening Ukraine’s ability to defend itself.” The words of the Democratic leader in the Senate Chuck Schumer were harsher: Trump considers a “friend the man who has kidnapped tens of thousands of children, killed tens of thousands of civilians and unjustly detained American citizens. He is embarrassing, despicable and frankly pathetic”.
There have also been controversies from the Maga world. Laura Loomer, the president’s conspiracy theorist ally, controversially observed that “since Putin is a ‘friend’ of Donald Trump, perhaps he could stop providing Iran with satellite imagery that is being used to kill US servicemen.” Crime master Don Winslow posted a series of fiery messages on X, in which he called the president a “disgusting, ignoble disgrace. The worst decision America has ever made.” Former American ambassador to Russia Michael McFaul is also harsh: “in calling Putin a friend, he is in stark contrast to American society.”
The controversies also concerned the trilateral with Xi, which for many resulted in a “photo opportunity” for Trump with no results. The White House had warned that there would be no breakthrough in the meeting with the presidents of Russia and China, but the final document with the word “peace” has raised more than a few doubts among commentators and observers. “Talking to everyone is fine, but they are not our friends,” several Republicans commented. “Trump confuses friends with our adversaries”, the Democrats added, convinced that the president should have cracked down on the two autocrats instead of bowing. At the trilateral table, Xi took center stage by placing himself between Putin and Trump and claiming a central role in diplomacy. Some analysts have noted that the Kremlin leader and Xi are the real winners of the historic meeting, as they confirmed that they can “transform the world order, usurping America’s role as the sole superpower”, noted the New York Times. At the table, Trump appeared the weakest politically: the president is not only a lame duck after the midterms but in two years he will leave the presidency in any case, while Putin and Xi will remain in office.
The avalanche of controversy, however, does not seem to shake Trump: in a message on Truth aboard Air Force One, he spoke of an “important and far-reaching” trip to China even if he failed to fulfill his desire for a meeting with the North Koran leader Kim Jong Un, and announced a press conference to talk about the successes achieved, about which many even within the Republican ranks have doubts.
